One of the bigger difficulties I’ve had with mental health medicine is, a good bit of the time I have no idea what those providing me advice and direction mean when they say things. Part of this is due to pop-psychology appropriating terminology and misusing it to the point of meaninglessness, and part of this is due to a large cognitive blind spot that seems to prevent me from parsing certain concepts.
I think the concept I have struggled most with, both in terms of time spent and results (or lack thereof) achieved, is the idea of “focus on the positive”. This has never made sense to me on what I think is a very basic level. All the words are common English words, the sentence is grammatically correct1, and yet I cannot figure out how it is supposed to be applied in the real world. It may as well be the sentence I stole to be the title of this post2. Or, more accurately maybe, its like looking at an Escher print. At a glance, everything looks okay but if someone told you to replicate it in three dimensions, you’d be hard pressed.
My trouble with the concept is not acknowledging the brief moments of happiness and joy that flit by occasionally, it’s with giving what I see as undue value and significance to them. I kind of see it like this3 – on one side of a balance scale, you have the core of a neutron star4. On the other side you have a pebble5. I have been assured that focusing on how much lighter the neutron star feels now that there is a pebble on the other side is the path to healing. I think my difficulty understanding how this is supposed to work in the real world is fairly self-evident.
Coming at this from a sightly different angle, my MHP has pointed out that I have a strong pattern of black-and-white thinking. Not a lot of grey area. Things are either all bad or not bad at all. If things are bad, they’ve always been bad. I can’t really disagree with him on this. Additionally, I have noticed in myself a tendency to rely heavily on avoidance and denial as coping mechanisms. These two traits combined, I think, explain the difficulty I have with the concept of “focus on the positive”. The pebble doesn’t fix the problem, and if you acknowledge the existence of the neutron star, then it’s there and you have to do something about it.
The trick, apparently, is learning to acknowledge the existence of the neutron star, while simultaneously being grateful for the pebble, even if it’s effect is negligible.
I’m not there yet.
Edited to add – The other difficulty I have with focusing on the positive is the challenge of being on fire and trying to focus on anything other than being on fire, but that’s a different post.